• 0 Posts
  • 39 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 11th, 2023

help-circle









  • Did you read that article, or just post the first news link you found with a headline that agreed with you?

    ‘No Evidence’ “Dr. Yi is an early and courageous individual to criticize China’s harmful birth control policies,” said Feng Wang, sociology professor at the University of California, Irvine.

    But Wang disputes Yi’s conclusions. “Scholars in China and at the U.N. have analyzed these and other data. Not a single person has ‘discovered’ such a huge discrepancy.”

    Everyone agrees to not accept China’s figures, but no one can find anywhere near such a big gulf. And you’d think that if they could, more US and Taiwanese sources would be reporting on it, wouldn’t they?



  • China, and maybe some other Asian countries have a household registration ( hukou 户口) system.

    Only people born into the system get to exist for things like schools, national insurance, etc.

    So any unofficially born second children (or hidden first born daughters) didn’t get to legally count under this.

    Also; children born out of marriage don’t exist for state schools or benefits, either.

    Where your hukou is limits your options for access to housing, claims on social security and health insurance, and the like. Mostly if you were born into a very rural area your only pathway to legally having a place to live and for your children to go to school in another part of the country is via university graduation.

    There are pushes to change this system, and smaller cities are removing their requirements for non-rural hukou. But Beijing, Shanghai, and other cities you have probably heard of are yet to do this.








  • That’s the UN data for Hong Kong, but it was easy enough to find the page for the PRC, excluding Hong Kong and Macao. The figures still line up well enough (noting, as the other page does that it exclude statistics about people interred in the “vocational training schools”), although the UN doesn’t have figures post 2016.

    UN page doesn’t seem to have execution rates either, which would also impact incarceration rates.

    Not to say that the US isn’t atrocious and also terrible on all those metrics, and plumbing new lows with each successive presidency. I was just kinda hoping for some more official PRC reported figures.